Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Kelly Toney
REALTOR®,
Associate Broker, GRI, ABR, RSPS
Chairman's Club 2022 & Circle of Excellence 2022
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Realtor.com Icon Zillow Icon 

Customer Reviews

testimonial quote

Kelly really kept our needs in mind throughout the process. And as first time home buyers offered her knowledge to us without hesitation. At no time did she make us feel pressured or rushed to buy.

The Carbajal’s, Dowagiac | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly is an amazing broker! She is extremely caring and always had the time to take no matter what time it was day or night to answer questions that my husband and I had regarding the process of the sale of our home. Kelly is a very warm hearted person and definately cares about her clients! She went above and beyond her job to make sure we were comfortable with every situation that came up. I would refer Kelly to anyone I knew that was interested in buying or selling a home.

Joe & Dawn West - Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was absolutely amazing! She goes above and beyond for her clients, very professional and overall working with her was fun! She's amazing! :)

Brittany Bolinger | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly is the best Realtor! Always accessible, and helpful. Very knowledgeable. I will absolutely recommend Kelly to friends and family

Patty , Niles MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was very professional & understood our unique circumstances. I have bought and sold many homes over the last 35 years. She is one of the top professionals I have dealt with in real estate. Ours was a challenging sale. We knew that after the first month on the market. She never let that get in the way. The overall experience was very good because of Kelly's positive attitude.

Tim Kilgore Charlotte | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly gave me the best experience for buying my first home. She explained everything to be and made sure we were checking all the boxes. Buying a home is stressful, but Kelly made it go smoothly. I can’t thank her enough for all of he hard work and attention to detail. When and if I need to ever sell or buy another home she will be the first one I call!

Natalie Kessler | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Thank you for finding our perfect forever home

Ashley Ralston | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I would definitely use Kelly again and I would recommend her to anyone buying or selling she was easy to work with and was on top of everything

Nathan Wilson dowagiac Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I can’t say it enough, Kelly Toney is amazing! We looked at homes for about 9 months, and had pretty specifics asks on what we were looking for and on budget. We looked at sooooooo many homes around Southwest Michigan and Kelly always made it work and never got tired of our questions or requests for showings! As a buyer in a sellers market I really felt like she had our backs. She cared more about protecting us from a bad investment than making money and gave us honest feedback on homes that weren’t going to be valued the same in a few years. Her knowledge about this area is vast and helpful. We had such a good time with her and I’m actually going to miss seeing her! To us Kelly Toney will always be considered a friend and I’m SO thankful we were referred to her and we’ll be referring all our family and friends to her!

Ashleigh Law- Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Difficult sale handled very well

l.Donald Pastorick | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Working with Kelly was great! She is so knowledgeable about everything that was needed to get complete and made it easy for us to do it all! She was an excellent communicator!

Amy, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I’ve known Kelly for years and knew I’d go with her if we ever sold our house. She is a very kind, caring and knowledgeable person. She kept us informed every step of the way and was always quick to respond to our questions. I will always recommend her to anyone that is selling their house or wanting to buy one in the area. Kelly was exceptional on every aspect of our house selling experience!

Robin Ligocki, formally Edwardsburg now in Arizona | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Anything I would say here would be redundant. Kelly was excellent to work with

Kevin and Jody Haislip, Niles | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney is awesome. I had a pleasant business experience with her 5 years ago, and she left a lasting impression. Kelly is a true asset to Cressy and Everett. Our house sold in record time. Kelly also found us our new home. The whole process was a smooth transition

Brian and Yvette Dell. Edwardsburg, Mi | Home Seller
testimonial quote

if we needed a real estate agent in the future we would definitely choose Kelly.

Bob & Linda Weaver | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney was very thorough and understanding of the importance of this sale. Continued to communicate with me and assured me what was going on and any issues being addressed. Excellent experience. A great friend and I appreciate all her caring. ❤ Sherry Losee firmly of Edwardsburg MI for 53 years.

Sherry Losee Edwardsburg Mi | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney was amazing! We were on the same page through everything, and that was a great, reassuring, feeling. I could tell she absolutely had our best interest in mind. Very thankful for her!! I will absolutely recommend Kelly to all my family and friends buying/selling a home. She’s very good at was she does, and it shows. Kelly is so personable, I’m really going to miss working with her!

Kristel Leaner, Cassopolis | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was always very professional and helpful. She was always there when I had questions or needed advice. I would definitely use her again.

Carroll L. Mead Jr. Niles Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly assisted us in the initial purchase of this same property back in 2010 and was an amazing asset. We knew we wanted her help with the sale. Kelly helped us to navigate a naturally stressful situation and set our minds at ease. She is extremely knowledgeable and attentive to detail. She is as effective and reliable as she is caring, and I couldn't imagine how differently our experience would have been without her. Kelly is phenomenal!

Sara LaMonds, Niles, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly did a great job.

Frank Heflin, Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly was a pleasure to work with. She clearly is extremely knowledgeable and helped educate us on the process of selling a home. She was very friendly, kind, and courteous to our family! I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a top notch Realtor!

Wendy Howe Constantine | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly helped me more than I could’ve asked for. She’s great at what she does, extremely competent and I would absolutely recommend her to friends and family in the future

Hayden Whisman, Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We saw that Kelly Toney had listed other lake property in the area so we contacted her. She was very knowledgeable, helpful and very easy to talk to. She also spent more time answering our questions ( I had lots of questions ) and discussing possible selling strategies than other realtors that we spoke to. She went to great lengths to address and resolve many of our particular issues and concerns. She met and exceeded my expectations across the board... I made the right choice when I selected Kelly to handle the sale of our property and am very happy with her overall performance and the final results...

Jerry P. South Bend | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney is a highly competent broker who demonstrates exceptional customer service. She was referred to my by a business associate. Selecting Kelly as my broker was a good decision because her performance, coupled by exceptional interpersonal skills and a friendly, professional disposition exceeded my expectations. After she sold one home, I immediately worked with her to list another home that received an asking price cash offer after being on the market for only 11 hours. Kelly Toney is an asset to Cressy & Everett - Edwardsburg. She represents the company well while meeting the needs of her customers. I am completely satisfied with my experience of working with Kelly and will use her whenever I have real estate needs in the area. She gets results!

Larry Waters, Elm Grove, WI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mrs. Toney has been actively involved in the real estate business in Edwardsburg since I moved to the area. She is knowledgeable, personable, and knows the market. She is also involved in the local schools, promoting strong education requirements, qualified staff, administrators, and arts and athletic programs. Kelly is a person that I have great confidence in. She has proven her abilities to me and sold more than one of my homes. An all around class act!

Nancy Turner, Edwardsburg Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I couldn’t have had a better realtor. Kelly kept me informed as to what to expect from the offer on my home,inspections and the closing. Whenever I called her she always was there to help me with my questions. Kelly is very polite and friendly. Kelly definitely knows her real estate! I will recommend Kelly to anyone I know who wants to sell their home. Everything from the for sale sign to the closing went smoothly. Couldn’t have been a better sale. Thank you Kelly Toney. I will nominate you realtor of the year!

Donna Horvath | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was top notch from beginning to end. She was professional, knowledgeable, helpful, available, well-connected in the community, responsive, friendly and personable. We could not have chosen a better realtor to assist us with the sale of our vacation home. Thank you, Kelly!! As I previously mentioned, we could not have chosen a better realtor to represent us and sell our home. Kelly helped us in our pre-sale preparations, helping us rapidly find the help we wanted to make sure our home was at its best so it would make an excellent presentation. We were rewarded with a great first week of many showings, and two full price offers. Kelly was friendly, professional, knowledgeable, available and responsive. She answered our questions before we needed to even ask because she is experienced, and in tune with her clients’ needs. We had a great experience working with Kelly. She sets the example for what a realtor should be. Thank you so very much!

Cathy and Michael Code, Naperville, IL | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Our neighbors had used Kelly when they sold their house and when we met Kelly, we knew she was the realtor for us. We hit it off immediately. Love her sense of humor and ease.

Cindi Dilley - Edwardsburg | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was fantastic! Kelly Made my first home buying experience a breeze. Always had a solution to a problem or an answer for one of my many questions. I would recommend to anyone looking for a house in this area!

Kyle Tengelitsch | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We would recommend using Kelly Toney and Cressy & Everett as their sales agent /broker to anyone in our area if they are searching for an honest, dependable realtor or agency.

Irene & Dennis Thompson | Home Seller
testimonial quote

This was my first home buying experience and Kelly made it perfect, she made it feel comfortable and was extremely knowledgeable with every question and concern I had. Kelly was exceedingly patient with my house picking and helped me to the fullest. I would highly recommend Kelly to anyone looking to purchase a home in Michigan.

Kyle Tengelitsch | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Super nice and very helpful, she took care of everything for and would always keep me updated on what was going on and what I needed to do. Being a first time home buyer I didn’t have a clue and she made it very easy!

Jacob woodill, Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney assisted me with the 1997 purchase of the property. I was ready to sell, and she has answered my questions and concerns through the years.

Donna Betsanes | Home Seller
testimonial quote

When selecting Kelly Toney to be our agent, we had very high expectations and she did not disappoint. Moreover, she exceeded our expectations in all areas; she was professional, highly competent, very helpful and attentive to our needs, pleasant, and fun to work with. We could not be more pleased with our choice and the results. We would highly recommend her.

Carolyn and Gary, Illinois | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I couldn't have found a better realtor. A co-worker suggested contacting Kelly Toney. My financial situation was horrible and I was concerned that she wouldn't be interested because I had very little time to sell the home. In less than a week she listed and sold my home!! She has been very caring and informative during the entire process. She turned a financial disaster for me into a positive outcome. She is a one of a kind person and I will forever be grateful for her compassion and help. I have been recommending her to everyone I know.

Elizabeth Strukel, Cassopolis | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Working with Kelly was great. She was very understanding and available when I had questions or concerns. She was very helpful throughout the process of buying my new home.

Stormie Barella, Union Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Pretty much what I stated previously I would recommend her to everyone that is buying a house. She is a wonderful person and very kind.

Dillon Cline Edwardsburg, Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney was always friendly, professional and on top of any issues we needed addressed. I would not hesitate to recommend her services to family & friends as I can think of nothing negative throughout our entire purchasing process. She answered anything questions we had and followed up thoroughly always in a very timely manner. I believe Cressy & Everett is fortunate to have Kelly Toney as one of their professional relators. If you look up "Professional Realtor" in the dictionary, I believe Kelly Toney's picture should appear!

Ron & Dawn Woolman - Granger, IN (and now also of Stone Lake) | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly gloria and I loved our experience with you not just as a realtor but as a neighbor friend and of course great realtor thank you for all that you did in the extra mile that you went thank you once again for all that you did for us good luck in the business David And Gloria

David Gouldman | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly is the best in the business! Very professional, and knowledgeable on all the questions that I had.

Michael Tepe | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We met Kelly at an open house she held and we clicked with her immediately. We received positive feedback from a number of friends when we mentioned meeting her. She really understands the local market and works hard to find properties that match with her clients. Kelly is a remarkable agent and has become a good friend through this process. She is a consummate professional, patient and kind in even the most intense situations. Kelly was amazing! She worked with us for over a year to find the right property for us. She was our advocate and offered us excellent advice when making our offer and in responding to inspection reports. Her passion for her job and for her clients was evident in every conversation and action.

Amy & Brian, Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I would recommend Kelly Toney to anyone I know. No matter what if a house sold by the time we could make an offer or something came up she always managed to bring my spirits up and onward to the next. Stress free and always brought positive vibes to every place we went

Ben Navarre Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

From start to finish of our real estate transaction Kelly did an amazing job handling our transaction

Dawn West, Cassopolis | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly is very professional and on top of things. She is prompt in returning calls and quick to get answers. We will use her for future purchases/sales. She is a pleasure to work with.

Dan & Jennifer Ramsey-Edwardsburg MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

It was an absolute pleasure working with Kelly. She gets my highest recommendation!

Steve Brown Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly sold my house on day one. She is amazing and gets my highest recommendations !

Steve Brown Edwardsburg | Home Seller
testimonial quote

This was a complicated sale as there were IRS Tax liens.. this property had been listed with two previous agencies. and could not get the lien release. and they were listing for far less money.. Met Kelly shared my needs and was down to the last straw as it was ready to be foreclosed on for back taxes. MS KELLY SAID I LOVE A CHALLENGE listed the property for far more than the other agencies...It sold and there was a closing !!! every challenge that came before us she took care of in a very joyful SPIRIT..She really really stands behind her clients. i have a few other pieces of property that i will be listing with her also.. she accomplished something that TWO OTHER AGENCIES COULDN'T I am so thankful !!!

Mary Pastorick Marcellus Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly did an amazing job. I would highly recommend her.

Steve B. Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly and I have started as business associates (she was the selling agent for Barron Lake when I bought it) and then turned into friends. She has always been extremely professional and honest with me all through the years.

Francine & Chuck Voreis- South Bend, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was a pleasure to work with and if we were selling a home anywhere near a lake we would definitely use her services.

Ruby, South Bend. | Home Seller
Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 09/30/2022. The listing information on this page last changed on 09/30/2022. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Fri 09/30/2022 8:12:13 AM EST) or GNIAR MLS (last updated Fri 09/30/2022 8:14:52 AM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Fri 09/30/2022 7:24:20 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved. --

Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Kelly Toney is licensed to sell real estate in the state of Michigan

Login to My Homefinder

Login to My Homefinder