Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Kelly Toney
Licensed in Michigan & Indiana | Chairman's Club 2025 | Circle of Excellence 2024
REALTOR®, Associate Broker, GRI, ABR, RSPS
(574) 215-9687
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Realtor.com Icon Zillow Icon VCard Icon 

Customer Reviews

testimonial quote

Kelly was great to work with. She put in the time to understand what I was looking for and then immediately got busy looking to find it. After finding a property in which I was interested, she continued to put in time helping me to be sure it was the right property and that I made the right offer.

Laurie, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly is very great to work with. Always professional and walks you threw the process. I would recommend her to all my friends and family. This is my 3rd house I have purchased with Kelly and it's always a blessing to have her help me find the perfect house for me and my family

Robert cline, Niles MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Great knowledge of the market, listens to our thoughts & needs to incorporate or address them. Fantastic communicator!

Andrew Bona, Granger, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney has been a trusted agent for our mother for many years and when Mom passed away it only made sense to trust Kelly with the final important task of selling the homestead. She was super helpful and considerate of our time and frankly, emotional state, while we tackled closing up the house. She went above and beyond expectations. Thank you, Kelly!

Dana Benkert, West Des Moines, Iowa | Home Seller
testimonial quote

She was very professional. Did all the leg work and kept me up with what was going on. The best realtor in my opinion. Would highly recommend her.

Susan Szymonski, Dowagiac | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We went to Kelly with questions with how selling our house would happen, what we needed to do etc. she didn't rush us into listing, she gave us a list of what needed to happen and we went from there. We were on a time restraint and she knew that, but didn't pressure us into selling for less than what we wanted. She knew what we wanted and took it very personally to get what we wanted. Over a great experience with Kelly. Would refer her to anyone looking to buy/sell a house.

Kyle Cline, Edwardsburg, Mi | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was terrific to work with, she treated my family like her own. Was very understanding with our concerns/needs. I would recommend Kelly to anyone looking to buy/sell a house. Her knowledge of real estate is unmatched. As usual buying/selling a house is stressful but having Kelly on your side makes it much easier.

Kyle Cline, Edwardsburg Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly was always available and honest. We appreciated her honesty and would recommend her to others. Thanks Kelly.

Deb and John Lendman, Edwardsburg, Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I've bought and sold many properties with Kelly and she is hands down the best realtor in the area. I don't use anyone but her.

Kyle Ramsey, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

She was professional & very helpful. I will recommend her to all my friends & family!

Charley Perry, Niles Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I know Kelly. She's honest, she listens, she gets results-- not just a sale, but a sense of satisfaction and closure that is often lacking elsewhere. She made sure we were informed at every stage, and was always ready to answer any question, no matter how small or silly it might have seemed to us. It wasn't easy to let go of a childhood home, but my siblings and I feel confident about the outcome, and Kelly's warmth and professionalism had a lot to do with that. We were highly satisfied with the way everything worked. It was smooth and hassle-free. We got the price we wanted, the type of buyer we were hoping for, and a smooth closing. Wonderful experience. I would recommend her to anyone wanting to put their cherished house on the market.

Lila Fair, Dowagiac | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was very knowledgeable about the area, our lake & property values & availability. She was always responsive to our questions, via phone calls & texts. The showings went well & timely. Her pricing of our lake house was spot on. We were out of town during the closing, so she handled it in our absence very well. She is professional, yet personable. Kelly was great!

Karen & John Thompson | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was honest and upfront about expectations. Her communication was excellent! No complaints. Awesome job!

Matthew Schwartz - Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

For us there was no alternative. My husband first met Kelly as the agent for the people who bought his previous home and he was impressed by her work ethics and personality. When we decided to move again about five years ago, Kelly was the only one we wanted to use. Now with this move we knew there was no better agent for us. Kelly really went to bat for us as we had an unusual situation come up not only for us but for Kelly & I would say Cressy & Everett. She worked so hard and really had our backs. No agent has ever worked so hard for us, and she is irreplaceable. Kelly Toney is not only the most courteous agent; she really knows the in's and outs of her business. She stands up for you, helps you find solutions, guides you through pre-listing, listing, selling and buying. I wouldn't recommend anyone else. It will always be Kelly Toney.

Yvette & Brian Dell | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I have used Kelly Toney many times over the years. She has become a friend of our family. Her personality combined with ethical values makes her second to none.

Brian and Yvette Dell 14266 Douglas Rd. Mishawaka, In | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

There are very few true professionals in any service industry. Kelly defines professional by her ability to anticipate what is needed to achieve a successful outcome and she makes it happen.

Bob Thompson, Edwardsburg | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelley is a veteran in the real estate business her actions speak for her self, by her success in the business

Randy Tighe Edwardsburg | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was fantastic, and an absolute pleasure to work with. She handled us at our most stressed with total patience and care. She was the perfect agent for our needs! Would recommend her to anyone.

Ryan Samson; Trevor, WI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly has been an acquaintance of my wife for many years, her outstanding performance in her career left no doubt in my mind that she was the perfect person to get my fathers house sold in a timely manner. And just as I expected she did just that! She was great to work with and very informative in helping me with things that would complete the sale of the house. I would definitely recommend her to anyone who is looking to sell a house or purchase one. She is a great lady!

Kurt Steven Cassopolis Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney was and has always been a blessing to work with! I called her last time I was looking for a new house, this time she sold it! She will be my forever realtor, if she can put up with me for that long lol. I would and do recommend Kelly to anyone interested in buy or selling a home! She was able to get my house sold and money in my bank in only one week! For 10,000 over asking! I couldn't be any happier with her and all her hard work♥️ Talking to Kelly is like talking to someone I grew up with! She is so friendly and humble.

Ben Navarre, Dowagiac | Home Seller
testimonial quote

If you are looking for a true professional in this area, there would be no need to look any further than Kelly

Bob Thompson Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I think Kelly did 100 percent on sale of my home. And the purchase of my new place. Thanks again Kelly Toney.

John Laubach. Niles. | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney took care of all of our questions and worries about buying a house for the first time. I would reccomend her to anyone in the area that need to buy property.

Marco Perez, Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

From start to finish the sale of the house went very smoothly.

Jason and Jody Hawkins | Home Seller
testimonial quote

From the moment I met, Kelly Toney, I trusted her and knew she would do the best she could for me! She was always available and always answered my questions right away. She listened to my concerns and helped me process. She went above and beyond!

Ruby Moyer, Edwardsburg | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was the best realtor I've ever worked with, and she will be the only realtor I work with from this day forward. She made the entire process so easy for us and was available any day, any time and we truly appreciated that. She is extremely flexible, friendly, and truly knows her stuff. I was very impressed by Kelly and I plan on referring all of my friends and family to her as well. 11/10.

Emily Ramsey | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly is very professional and caring. She knew what was best for selling my house and she did a great job! I would recommend Kelly to all of my friends!

Beckie Mishawaka Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney was phenomenal! I would recommend her to everyone! Shirley brehm was excellent as well

Beckie, Mishawaka Indiana | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Beckie, Mishawaka Indiana | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly is the best I've ever worked with. I have bought several investment properties and will continue to do so but from now on I'll be using Kelly for the selling and the buying of future properties. Her understanding of the market, inspections, value, etc. is unmatched. Whether you're selling a home or purchasing, Kelly is the way to go. If you're a buyer, she is unbelievably thorough to make sure you are buying a quality property with no hidden issues or surprises all while getting you the best deal. If you're a seller, she sets the bar for communication of what needs to be done, she is calm in the bidding/offering phase to make sure you get the highest offer, and her resources are endless when it comes to needing contractors to repair issues if any are found on the inspections. So, if you've decided to list your home or you're looking to purchase, I promise you that you will never need to look for another realtor again after you go with Kelly!

Kyle Ramsey, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly really kept our needs in mind throughout the process. And as first time home buyers offered her knowledge to us without hesitation. At no time did she make us feel pressured or rushed to buy.

The Carbajal’s, Dowagiac | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly is an amazing broker! She is extremely caring and always had the time to take no matter what time it was day or night to answer questions that my husband and I had regarding the process of the sale of our home. Kelly is a very warm hearted person and definately cares about her clients! She went above and beyond her job to make sure we were comfortable with every situation that came up. I would refer Kelly to anyone I knew that was interested in buying or selling a home.

Joe & Dawn West - Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was absolutely amazing! She goes above and beyond for her clients, very professional and overall working with her was fun! She's amazing! :)

Brittany Bolinger | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly is the best Realtor! Always accessible, and helpful. Very knowledgeable. I will absolutely recommend Kelly to friends and family

Patty , Niles MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was very professional & understood our unique circumstances. I have bought and sold many homes over the last 35 years. She is one of the top professionals I have dealt with in real estate. Ours was a challenging sale. We knew that after the first month on the market. She never let that get in the way. The overall experience was very good because of Kelly's positive attitude.

Tim Kilgore Charlotte | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly gave me the best experience for buying my first home. She explained everything to be and made sure we were checking all the boxes. Buying a home is stressful, but Kelly made it go smoothly. I can’t thank her enough for all of he hard work and attention to detail. When and if I need to ever sell or buy another home she will be the first one I call!

Natalie Kessler | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

None. All are mentioned in the first block.

John and Susan Somers | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

John and Susan Somers | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I would definitely use Kelly again and I would recommend her to anyone buying or selling she was easy to work with and was on top of everything

Nathan Wilson dowagiac Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Thank you for finding our perfect forever home

Ashley Ralston | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I can’t say it enough, Kelly Toney is amazing! We looked at homes for about 9 months, and had pretty specifics asks on what we were looking for and on budget. We looked at sooooooo many homes around Southwest Michigan and Kelly always made it work and never got tired of our questions or requests for showings! As a buyer in a sellers market I really felt like she had our backs. She cared more about protecting us from a bad investment than making money and gave us honest feedback on homes that weren’t going to be valued the same in a few years. Her knowledge about this area is vast and helpful. We had such a good time with her and I’m actually going to miss seeing her! To us Kelly Toney will always be considered a friend and I’m SO thankful we were referred to her and we’ll be referring all our family and friends to her!

Ashleigh Law- Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Difficult sale handled very well

l.Donald Pastorick | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Working with Kelly was great! She is so knowledgeable about everything that was needed to get complete and made it easy for us to do it all! She was an excellent communicator!

Amy, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I’ve known Kelly for years and knew I’d go with her if we ever sold our house. She is a very kind, caring and knowledgeable person. She kept us informed every step of the way and was always quick to respond to our questions. I will always recommend her to anyone that is selling their house or wanting to buy one in the area. Kelly was exceptional on every aspect of our house selling experience!

Robin Ligocki, formally Edwardsburg now in Arizona | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Anything I would say here would be redundant. Kelly was excellent to work with

Kevin and Jody Haislip, Niles | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney is awesome. I had a pleasant business experience with her 5 years ago, and she left a lasting impression. Kelly is a true asset to Cressy and Everett. Our house sold in record time. Kelly also found us our new home. The whole process was a smooth transition

Brian and Yvette Dell. Edwardsburg, Mi | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We gave our testimonial in the body of the survey.

Lewis and Rosema Jackson property sold @ 60576 White Temple Rd. Vandalia, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Lewis and Rosema Jackson property sold @ 60576 White Temple Rd. Vandalia, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

if we needed a real estate agent in the future we would definitely choose Kelly.

Bob & Linda Weaver | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney was very thorough and understanding of the importance of this sale. Continued to communicate with me and assured me what was going on and any issues being addressed. Excellent experience. A great friend and I appreciate all her caring. ❤ Sherry Losee firmly of Edwardsburg MI for 53 years.

Sherry Losee Edwardsburg Mi | Home Seller
Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 10/29/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 10/29/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Thu 10/29/2026 9:57:20 PM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Thu 10/29/2026 6:48:35 AM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Thu 10/29/2026 9:44:52 PM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Thu 10/29/2026 9:52:35 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Kelly Toney is licensed to sell real estate in the state of Michigan

Login to My Homefinder