Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Kelly Toney
Licensed in Michigan & Indiana | Chairman's Club 2025 | Circle of Excellence 2024
REALTOR®, Associate Broker, GRI, ABR, RSPS
(574) 215-9687
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Realtor.com Icon Zillow Icon VCard Icon 

Customer Reviews

testimonial quote

Kelly was amazing at making sure the process went as smooth as possible and we were educated on what was happening the entire time as first time homebuyers. I could not recommend Kelly enough to others. She is truly the best!

Alexis Stacy, Niles, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Erik and Karen Malling, South Bend, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Top number one agent in our book! Personable communicative understanding prompt knowledgeable kind professional friendly. Was exactly what we needed in selling our home very responsive to questions and concerns throughout the sell and closing.

Erik and Karen Malling, South Bend, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was great to work with! She was very personable and made the process easy for me. I would definitely recommend working with her!

Cole Bogunia, Buchanan, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney is professional, knowledgable, experienced and a truely well equiped advisor on any real estate transaction. I just think the world of her and how much she helps in any real estate transaction. I highly value her opinion.

Jim, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly was quick on responding and getting things needed for purchase and closing. A pleasure to work with.

David Woodill, Edwardsburg, MI. | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Amazing service and knowledge Wonderful realtor, kept us informed and guided us every step of the way Couldn't have asked for anything more Communication was perfect She did a great job selling our home

Niki Vascil, Niles MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Our needs were very specific, but in the most difficult market conditions imaginable, Kelly found exactly what we wanted and helped us get it under market value. Our home purchase was a small collection of miracles guided by Kelly Toney's persistence, wisdom and experience. Thanks Kelly, you have our highest recommendation.

Doug & Virginia Smith, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly was the best realtor I could have possibly asked for. She was available any time, any day if I needed to ask I question about a house. She promptly got back to me with responses. She always had my best interest in mind and the future. Kelly was a pleasure to work with and I would recommend her to everyone buying in Indiana and Michigan.

Toni Kozlowicz, Edwardsburg, Mi. | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

When we bought the property we used Kelly so when we decided to sell there was no question we were going to use Kelly. Her knowledge and expertise process made the process go smoothly.

Meryl A Christensen, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We were referred to Kelly by another realtor in the area and am so glad that we were. Kelly is exceptional at her job, professional, responsive, and easy to work with. Have bought and sold several properties before and she is, by far, the best! She is our go-to realtor for any buy/sell needs going forward!

Julianne Billington, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

My neighbor recommended Kelly Toney when I asked her for advice about selling my second home. My first contact with her I knew she would do a great job on my behalf in all the details to accomplish this. This experience was very positive, she was always promped and knowledgeable in answering my questions. I would highly recommend her to assist anyone who is looking for a peaceful and professional experience in selling or buying a home. I can't thank her enought for such a great experience!

Maureen A Smith, Edwardsburg,Mi | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was very experienced in her field. She has a depth of knowledge and experience that I very much needed to sell my mom's house. She went above and beyond in communication. Very responsive no matter the question. Advised if there was things I had to sign. Her guidance got me through a tough time. Highly recommend to anyone.

Mary Sandstrom Pontius, South Bend Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly embellishes the best of the best in every way!! Would utilize her skills again!!

Richard Gates, Edwardsburg. MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Aside from Kelly Toney's years of experience and professionalism, she is also an exceptional human being. From day one we perceived her empathy and compassion for her clients and the process that they are embarking upon. She skillfully guided us to a successful conclusion of that journey. What could have been a difficult task was made easier thanks to Kelly. Best wishes for the future. Dennis and Lorraine Ryan

Dennis and Lorraine Ryan, Niles, Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly went above and beyond to assist in the sale of our home. She gets our highest recommendation.

Nancy and Ed Schultz, Homosassa Florida | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Great job

Dan lonergan, Buchanan Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly is the best Realtor thatI have ever worked with. She is professional, polite and thorough. I have already recommended her to a couple of associates who are contemplating relocation.

Brian Dell, Niles, Mi. 49120 | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was wonderful to work with on our property purchase. She was straight forward, helpful, and attentive to our questions and concerns. Always returned our calls and texts. We would highly recommend her and her company.

Kevin Kaiser, Sturgis, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly is a class act from start to finish. Very professional regarding each step of the process. Always communicated with us regarding showings and future inspections. Would highly recommend for any real estate transaction.

Jon Carlson, Benton Harbor | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was referred to me by my mother who had work with Kelly years ago. Kelly was very quick, responsive and thorough. Not only did she help with the purchase of this particular property and getting the property staked with recorded boundary survey, she was also able to facilitate getting our other two properties staked and recorded at the same time, which I'm sure saved some money overall. It is a piece of mind to have this work performed. Thank you very much, I will definately use and/or recommend Kelly in the future.

Justin Neuerburg, Cassopolis, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney is an amazing person and realtor. She helped us with the negotiation and purchase of our new property and now the sale of our existing house. As a business owner I understand the need to have key employees. Kelly has the Experience, Knowledge and Attitude to help anyone with a smooth transition into a purchase or sell. We highly recommend her to everyone.

Mark & Leslie Navarre, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was very professional and helpfule thought the intire process. Her knowledge of the area and years of experiance was very much helpful. I would reconomend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She was Awesome!

Ron R, Edwardsburg MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was professional and helped us every step of the way. It took awhile to find what we were looking for and Kelly was very patient with us. After finding a house, we ran into a few problems and Kelly was positive and helped us get through it. We would definitely recommend her to anyone!

Nicole Andrich and Zach Grey, White Pigeon, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We highly recommend Kelly to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Her passion for realestate and her clients truly sets her apart. From the moment we started working with her it was clear that we were in good hands. Because of her exceptional marketing skills and understanding of the market we had a bona fide offer with 48 hrs. Her professionalism and dedication didn't stop there, she ensured that the entire closing process went off without a hitch. Kelly's attention to detail and commitment to her clients made what could have been a stressful experience seamless and enjoyable. We are grateful for her hard work and expertise.

p.p. R.L., Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly does an amazing job. I needed someone who could hold my hand and walk me through the process of selling my home and Kelly was perfect for me. She is a straight forward person and knows so much about the business and I knew I could trust her to do the best for me. She made selling the home I loved much easier. I will recommend her and Cressy Everett to anyone who is looking to buy and/or sell their properties. She was a blessing and I appreciate her efforts on my behalf.

Karol VanOrman, Niles, Mi / PawPaw, Mi | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I've used Kelly many times for the buying and selling of land and houses. Cant recommend her enough! She is thorough, goes above and beyond in all aspects and gets the job done over and over again. 10/10 in every category!

Kyle Ramsey, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was amazing to work with! She understood the needs of our family in regards to selling our home. She made it such an easy and stress-free experience. I would recommend Kelly to anyone looking to sell their home. She was knowledgeable, honest, understanding and really cared about us. She kept us informed every step of the way. I look forward to working with her in the future.

Arminda Dussel, Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was great to work with. She put in the time to understand what I was looking for and then immediately got busy looking to find it. After finding a property in which I was interested, she continued to put in time helping me to be sure it was the right property and that I made the right offer.

Laurie, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly is very great to work with. Always professional and walks you threw the process. I would recommend her to all my friends and family. This is my 3rd house I have purchased with Kelly and it's always a blessing to have her help me find the perfect house for me and my family

Robert cline, Niles MI | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Great knowledge of the market, listens to our thoughts & needs to incorporate or address them. Fantastic communicator!

Andrew Bona, Granger, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney has been a trusted agent for our mother for many years and when Mom passed away it only made sense to trust Kelly with the final important task of selling the homestead. She was super helpful and considerate of our time and frankly, emotional state, while we tackled closing up the house. She went above and beyond expectations. Thank you, Kelly!

Dana Benkert, West Des Moines, Iowa | Home Seller
testimonial quote

She was very professional. Did all the leg work and kept me up with what was going on. The best realtor in my opinion. Would highly recommend her.

Susan Szymonski, Dowagiac | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We went to Kelly with questions with how selling our house would happen, what we needed to do etc. she didn't rush us into listing, she gave us a list of what needed to happen and we went from there. We were on a time restraint and she knew that, but didn't pressure us into selling for less than what we wanted. She knew what we wanted and took it very personally to get what we wanted. Over a great experience with Kelly. Would refer her to anyone looking to buy/sell a house.

Kyle Cline, Edwardsburg, Mi | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was terrific to work with, she treated my family like her own. Was very understanding with our concerns/needs. I would recommend Kelly to anyone looking to buy/sell a house. Her knowledge of real estate is unmatched. As usual buying/selling a house is stressful but having Kelly on your side makes it much easier.

Kyle Cline, Edwardsburg Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kelly was always available and honest. We appreciated her honesty and would recommend her to others. Thanks Kelly.

Deb and John Lendman, Edwardsburg, Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I've bought and sold many properties with Kelly and she is hands down the best realtor in the area. I don't use anyone but her.

Kyle Ramsey, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

She was professional & very helpful. I will recommend her to all my friends & family!

Charley Perry, Niles Michigan | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I know Kelly. She's honest, she listens, she gets results-- not just a sale, but a sense of satisfaction and closure that is often lacking elsewhere. She made sure we were informed at every stage, and was always ready to answer any question, no matter how small or silly it might have seemed to us. It wasn't easy to let go of a childhood home, but my siblings and I feel confident about the outcome, and Kelly's warmth and professionalism had a lot to do with that. We were highly satisfied with the way everything worked. It was smooth and hassle-free. We got the price we wanted, the type of buyer we were hoping for, and a smooth closing. Wonderful experience. I would recommend her to anyone wanting to put their cherished house on the market.

Lila Fair, Dowagiac | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was very knowledgeable about the area, our lake & property values & availability. She was always responsive to our questions, via phone calls & texts. The showings went well & timely. Her pricing of our lake house was spot on. We were out of town during the closing, so she handled it in our absence very well. She is professional, yet personable. Kelly was great!

Karen & John Thompson | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was honest and upfront about expectations. Her communication was excellent! No complaints. Awesome job!

Matthew Schwartz - Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

For us there was no alternative. My husband first met Kelly as the agent for the people who bought his previous home and he was impressed by her work ethics and personality. When we decided to move again about five years ago, Kelly was the only one we wanted to use. Now with this move we knew there was no better agent for us. Kelly really went to bat for us as we had an unusual situation come up not only for us but for Kelly & I would say Cressy & Everett. She worked so hard and really had our backs. No agent has ever worked so hard for us, and she is irreplaceable. Kelly Toney is not only the most courteous agent; she really knows the in's and outs of her business. She stands up for you, helps you find solutions, guides you through pre-listing, listing, selling and buying. I wouldn't recommend anyone else. It will always be Kelly Toney.

Yvette & Brian Dell | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I have used Kelly Toney many times over the years. She has become a friend of our family. Her personality combined with ethical values makes her second to none.

Brian and Yvette Dell 14266 Douglas Rd. Mishawaka, In | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

There are very few true professionals in any service industry. Kelly defines professional by her ability to anticipate what is needed to achieve a successful outcome and she makes it happen.

Bob Thompson, Edwardsburg | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelley is a veteran in the real estate business her actions speak for her self, by her success in the business

Randy Tighe Edwardsburg | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly was fantastic, and an absolute pleasure to work with. She handled us at our most stressed with total patience and care. She was the perfect agent for our needs! Would recommend her to anyone.

Ryan Samson; Trevor, WI | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly has been an acquaintance of my wife for many years, her outstanding performance in her career left no doubt in my mind that she was the perfect person to get my fathers house sold in a timely manner. And just as I expected she did just that! She was great to work with and very informative in helping me with things that would complete the sale of the house. I would definitely recommend her to anyone who is looking to sell a house or purchase one. She is a great lady!

Kurt Steven Cassopolis Michigan | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kelly Toney was and has always been a blessing to work with! I called her last time I was looking for a new house, this time she sold it! She will be my forever realtor, if she can put up with me for that long lol. I would and do recommend Kelly to anyone interested in buy or selling a home! She was able to get my house sold and money in my bank in only one week! For 10,000 over asking! I couldn't be any happier with her and all her hard work♥️ Talking to Kelly is like talking to someone I grew up with! She is so friendly and humble.

Ben Navarre, Dowagiac | Home Seller
testimonial quote

If you are looking for a true professional in this area, there would be no need to look any further than Kelly

Bob Thompson Edwardsburg | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I think Kelly did 100 percent on sale of my home. And the purchase of my new place. Thanks again Kelly Toney.

John Laubach. Niles. | Home Buyer
Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 05/27/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 05/27/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Wed 05/27/2026 1:09:06 PM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Wed 05/27/2026 1:08:26 PM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Wed 05/27/2026 1:05:09 PM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Wed 05/27/2026 1:03:05 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Kelly Toney is licensed to sell real estate in the state of Michigan

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel